Univ. Aix-Marseille III Chimie théOrique et Modélisation, CTOM CTOM
 
Getting the Weights of Lewis Structures out of Hückel Theory:
Hückel-Lewis Configuration Interaction (HL-CI)

Stéphane Humbel J. Chem. Educ. 2007 84 , 1056-1061

A scheme, to obtain the weights of resonating Lewis structures from Hückel calculations, is presented and tested against established ab initio methods. In this paper we make use of the fact that the solution of the Schrödinger equation can be written in any base. When the Hückel solution is written in the base of two Lewis structures (resonance contributors), the off-diagonal term of the corresponding Hamiltonian matrix is easily obtained, and can be used to calculate the weights of each resonance contributor.

The formamide resonance is used as a example. Ab initio computations lead to a major structure I at 66% (minor is II at 34%).

Lets write the delocalized state (resonant hybrid) as a linear combination of the Lewis structures (resonant contributors): &PsiTot= CI &PsiI+ CII &PsiII. We can consider &PsiI and &PsiII as an orthonormal basis that we use to write an Hamiltonian matrix whose solution is the delocalized state (&PsiTot,ETot) described at the Hückel level. From this completed Hamiltonian one finds easily CI and CII. The weights found with the HL-CI approach are the square of the coefficients (e.g. CI2). The values we obtain are consistent with those found with the NRT method. More importantly for the educational purpose, they are consistent with the predictable trends.

Note that if I is the lowest resonance structure, the resonance energy is ΔEI.

This simple scheme creates an additional link between Hückel theory and usual organic chemistry concepts such as Lewis structures and resonance. Because the Lewis structures can be considered as configurations, the scheme can be used to exemplify Configuration Interaction (CI) concepts with meaningful configurations, hence the name "Hückel-Lewis CI" (HL-CI) given for the scheme.


 
Further readings & informations
  • The approach is extended to 3 and more resonating structures in Hückel Theory for Lewis Structures: Hückel-Lewis Configuration Interaction (HL-CI) D. Hagebaum-Reignier, R. Girardi, Y. Carissan and S. Humbel J. Mol. Struct. (THEOCHEM) 2007, 817 99-109.

  • The Hückel Hamiltonian matrix is easily obtained from the major structure. That of the individual structures are obtained from this hamiltonian by zeroing out the appropriate matrix element (here in red). Having all the energies of the structures it is straigthforward to build the Configuration Interaction hamiltonian.

  • Lewis-Based Valence Bond Scheme: Application to the Allyl Cation M. Linares, B. Braïda, S. Humbel J. Phys. Chem. A 2006, 110, 2505-2509. JPC-2006
  • Review on NBO & NRT Methods and their Applications: (a) A. E. Reed, L. A. Curtiss and F. Weinhold Chem. Rev. 1988, 88, 899-926. (b) Weinhold, F.; Carpenter, J.E. in The Structure of Small Molecules and Ions; Naaman, R.; Vager, Z.; Eds.; , Plenum: New York, NY 1988
  • See also the web page of NBO 5.0 that we used with Gaussian 98. NBO 5.0
  • Java program called SHMO2 made by A. Rauk's group.
    Our code that includes Lewis mesomeric effects in Hückel calculations : Java applet for Huckel and mesomery calculations (HuLis)

    2006